EN8 Steel VS 1045 Steel VS EN9 Steel:Hardcore Comparison, Who Wins?
Steel is the “skeleton” of industrial manufacturing, and different types carry different missions! When EN8, EN9 and 1045 steels appeared on the same stage, an in-depth competition on performance, characteristics and applications has begun. From hardness, toughness to processing difficulty, from gear forging in mechanical manufacturing to structural construction in the construction field, what scenarios are they suitable for? And how to choose accurately according to needs? The following is a comprehensive comparative analysis of EN8, EN9 (British BS 970 standard) and 1045 steel (ASTM standard), covering standard background, composition differences, performance characteristics and industrial applications:
1. Standard Background and International Correspondence
EN8 and EN9 are classic carbon steel grades in the British BS 970 standard (1991 edition), which are widely used in the field of mechanical manufacturing. 1045 steel is a general medium carbon steel under the ASTM standard (corresponding to the European standard C45 steel). The international correspondence between the three is as follows:
| Material | Standard system | Typical grades | Equivalent international grades |
| EN8 Steel | BS 970 | 080M40 | ASTM 1040/1045 |
| EN9 Steel | BS 970 | 070M55 | ASTM 1055 |
| 1045 Steel | ASTM A29 | 1045 | EN C45 |
2. Chemical Composition Comparison
| Material | Carbon (C) | Manganese (Mn) | Silicon (Si) | Sulfur (S) | Phosphorus (P) |
| EN8 Steel | 0.36-0.44% | 0.60-1.00% | ≤0.40% | ≤0.050% | ≤0.050% |
| EN9 Steel | 0.50-0.60% | 0.50-0.80% | ≤0.40% | ≤0.050% | ≤0.050% |
| 1045 Steel | 0.43-0.50% | 0.60-0.90% | 0.15-0.35% | ≤0.050% | ≤0.040% |
Summary of composition differences:
- Carbon content: EN9 (high carbon) > 1045 (medium-high carbon) > EN8 (medium carbon);
- Silicon control: EN8/EN9 has a higher silicon limit (≤0.40%), which may affect cutting performance;
- Impurity limits: BS 970 has a similar tolerance to sulfur and phosphorus as ASTM 1045.
3. Comparison of Mechanical Properties (Quenched and Tempered State)
| Material | Tensile strength (MPa) | Yield strength (MPa) | Elongation (%) | Hardness (HB) | Impact toughness (J) |
| EN8 Steel | 550-800 | 300-450 | 14-20 | 170-220 | 20-30 |
| EN9 Steel | 700-950 | 450-600 | 8-12 | 220-280 | 10-20 |
| 1045 Steel | 570-850 | 310-460 | 12-18 | 180-230 | 20-35 |
Performance characteristics:
- Strength and hardness: EN9 > 1045 > EN8 (carbon content dominates the difference);
- Toughness: 1045 is the best, EN8 is the second, and EN9 is the lowest (high carbon brittleness is significant);
- Hardenability: EN9 requires strict process control, 1045 and EN8 are easier to handle.
4. Heat Treatment Process and Core Objectives
| Material | Quenching temperature | Cooling medium | Tempering temperature | Process target |
| EN8 Steel | 820-850℃ | Oil cooling | 550-650℃ | Balance between strength and toughness |
| EN9 Steel | 800-830℃ | Oil cooling/stage cooling | 400-500℃ | High hardness and wear resistance |
| 1045 Steel | 840-870℃ | Water/oil | 500-600℃ | Low-cost comprehensive performance optimization |
Key points of the process:
- EN8/EN9: forced oil cooling to avoid the risk of cracking of high carbon steel;
- 1045 steel: water cooling can increase hardness, but deformation needs to be controlled;
- Tempering strategy: EN9 low temperature tempering retains hardness, 1045 medium temperature tempering balances performance.
5. Typical Application Scenarios
| Material | Applicable fields |
| EN8 Steel | Medium-load transmission shafts, gears, bolts (need quenching and tempering) |
| EN9 Steel | High-stress springs, wear-resistant tools (punches, dies), heavy-duty pins (need surface hardening) |
| 1045 Steel | General mechanical parts (crankshafts, connecting rods), automotive parts (low-cost mass production) |
Replacement suggestions:
- EN8 ↔ 1045: Similar performance, interchangeable, need to adjust heat treatment parameters (such as oil quenching to water quenching);
- EN9 ↔ ASTM 1055: High carbon steel interchange is more reasonable, 1045 cannot meet the high wear resistance requirements.
6. Processing and Cost Analysis
| Features | EN8 steel | EN9 steel | 1045 steel |
| Machinability | Good (medium carbon steel) | Poor (high carbon hardness) | Excellent (balanced composition) |
| Weldability | Preheating required | Strict preheating required | Preheating required |
| Economy | Medium (Europe) | High | Low (global supply) |
7. Selection Decision Guide
1. Performance requirements:
– High wear resistance/hardness → EN9 or ASTM 1055;
– Medium strength → EN8 or 1045.
2. Cost control:
– Prioritize low cost → 1045 steel;
– Prioritize performance → EN series.
3. Process conditions:
– Simple heat treatment → 1045 steel;
– Controllable quenching equipment → EN8/EN9.
Summary
Through an in-depth comparison of EN8, EN9, and 1045 steels, it can be found that each type of steel has its own unique performance advantages and adaptation scenarios. EN8 has a place in the manufacturing of ordinary mechanical parts with its good comprehensive mechanical properties; EN9 has become a reliable choice for fields with high strength and toughness requirements with its excellent hardenability and wear resistance; 1045 steel has excellent performance in the manufacturing of various shafts, bolts and other parts with its moderate carbon content, stable cutting performance and good surface treatment effect. In actual production and application, only by fully understanding their characteristic differences can we accurately match the needs, so that different steels can maximize their value in their respective fields of expertise and provide solid material support for industrial manufacturing.
Interactive topic: If you need an in-depth analysis of specific working conditions (such as fatigue loads, low temperature environments), Welcome to discuss together!
MORE ABOUT EN8,EN9 AND 1045 STEEL
